Sunday , August 9 2020
Home / Constantin Gurdgiev: True Economics / 3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

Summary:
ECB's money-printing press has been running overtime these weeks. So let's put the Euro area central banks' monetary policy shenanigans into perspective, comparing them to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) related measures, the Euro area sovereign debt crisis and the subsequent painful recovery: Good thing: ECB has deployed COVID19 response at scale and fast. Bad thing: it is highly uncertain how much growth all of this activism is going to sustain. From 2000 through 1Q 2020, there is zero (statistically) relationship between current GDP growth (nominal) and ECB assets accumulation in the same year and in prior year: Even ignoring statistical significance, the relationship itself is not positive, especially in the lagged data. In other words, there is absolutely no evidence of

Topics:
[email protected] (TrueEconomics) considers the following as important: , , , , , , , , , , ,

This could be interesting, too:

Yves Smith writes Patrick Cockburn: War and Pandemic Journalism

Yves Smith writes Stimulus Talks on Verge of Failure as Both Sides Trade Blame

Yves Smith writes Mass Gatherings Contributed to Early COVID-19 Mortality: Evidence from US Sports

Yves Smith writes Washington Going Full Andrew Mellon as Stimulus Talks Drag, Inadequate Support Guaranteed


ECB's money-printing press has been running overtime these weeks. So let's put the Euro area central banks' monetary policy shenanigans into perspective, comparing them to the Global Financial Crisis (GFC) related measures, the Euro area sovereign debt crisis and the subsequent painful recovery:

3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

Good thing: ECB has deployed COVID19 response at scale and fast. Bad thing: it is highly uncertain how much growth all of this activism is going to sustain. From 2000 through 1Q 2020, there is zero (statistically) relationship between current GDP growth (nominal) and ECB assets accumulation in the same year and in prior year:
3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

Even ignoring statistical significance, the relationship itself is not positive, especially in the lagged data. In other words, there is absolutely no evidence of causality from ECB asset purchases to higher economic growth. While reasons for this results are complex (and not really a matter for this post), there are some serious questions to be asked as to how much tangible growth is being sustained by the Central Bank's activism. On the other side of the same argument, if we assume that the ECB purchases of assets are effective at sustaining growth in the Euro area economy, then we must have some serious questions as to what the Euro area economy is capable of producing in terms of GDP growth without such interventions.

In simple terms: we are damned if we do, and damned if we do not:

  • Either monetary activism is not effective at sustaining growth, or
  • If monetary activism is effective, then the state of the economic institutions overall is so dire, it remains comatose even with extraordinary supports from Frankfurt.

Neither is a pleasant conclusion. And there is not a third alternative.

Just in case you need a reality check on how poor Euro area's growth has been, here is a summary:

3/7/20: ECB Jumping the Proverbial Shark?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *